A property management company with 150 units ran their entire maintenance operation from a Google Sheet. Work orders, vendor assignments, completion tracking, cost records — all in one massive spreadsheet with 47 columns and over 3,000 rows.
It worked. For a while.
Then a tenant reported a burst pipe on a Friday night. The on-call manager opened the spreadsheet on her phone, tried to find the preferred plumber for that property, and watched the screen freeze. She called the wrong vendor. The vendor didn't serve that area. The pipe flooded the unit below. The repair bill tripled.
The spreadsheet didn't cause the pipe to burst. But it turned a manageable emergency into an expensive one.
Spreadsheets are one of the greatest business tools ever made. They're free, they're flexible, and everybody knows how to use them. But there's a point — and most growing businesses hit it — where the spreadsheet stops helping and starts hurting. We see it constantly: a business that's ready for custom software but doesn't realize it yet because the spreadsheet still technically "works."
Here are the five signs you've reached that point.
Sign 1: Multiple People Edit the Same Sheet
When it was just you, the spreadsheet was perfect. You knew every column, every formula, every color-coding convention. You could find anything in seconds.
Then you shared it with your team.
Now Sarah sorts by date and accidentally breaks Tom's filter. Tom adds a column that shifts all of Maria's formulas. Maria copies a row and doesn't notice she overwrote the formula in column Q.
Nobody is doing anything wrong. Spreadsheets just weren't designed for multiple people to work in them simultaneously — despite what the "real-time collaboration" marketing says. They're designed for one person's view of one dataset.
The telltale sign: You've had at least one moment of "who changed this?" followed by 20 minutes of detective work trying to figure out what happened to the data.
Sign 2: You're Spending More Time Maintaining the Sheet Than Using It
The spreadsheet was supposed to save time. And it did — at first. But somewhere along the way, maintaining it became a job in itself.
Copying last month's data into this month's tab. Updating formulas when the business rules change. Formatting reports for the Monday meeting. Fixing broken references. Rebuilding pivot tables that stopped working.
One business owner we talked to estimated she spent six hours a week maintaining three critical spreadsheets. That's 312 hours a year — almost eight full work weeks — spent on data entry and spreadsheet maintenance instead of running her business.
The telltale sign: You or someone on your team has "update the spreadsheet" as a recurring task that takes more than 30 minutes a week.
Sign 3: You Can't Answer Basic Questions Without a Project
"How many new customers did we get this quarter compared to last quarter?"
In a proper system, that's a click. In a spreadsheet, that's a research project. You have to figure out which tab has the data, whether it's formatted consistently, whether the date column is actually dates or text that looks like dates, and whether anyone accidentally deleted rows from last quarter.
When answering routine business questions requires 30 minutes of data archaeology, your tool is holding you back.
The telltale sign: You've stopped asking certain business questions because getting the answer from the spreadsheet is too much work.
Sign 4: You've Built Workarounds on Top of Workarounds
The spreadsheet needed a dropdown for status values, so you added data validation. Then you needed to trigger an email when something changed status, so you added a Google Apps Script. Then you needed a dashboard, so you built a separate summary sheet with VLOOKUP formulas pulling from the main sheet.
Now you have a Frankenstein system held together by formulas, scripts, conditional formatting rules, and a README tab that nobody reads.
Each workaround solved a real problem. But stacked together, they've created something that only one person understands — and that person is terrified of changing anything because they don't know what will break.
The telltale sign: There's one person in your company who is the only one who truly understands how the spreadsheet works. If they leave, you're in trouble. This is also the same problem that kills AI projects — critical knowledge locked in one person's head instead of in a system.
Sign 5: The Spreadsheet Has Become Mission-Critical
This is the big one. Your spreadsheet started as a convenience. Now your business can't function without it.
Customer records. Job scheduling. Inventory tracking. Financial reporting. If the spreadsheet disappeared tomorrow, how much of your operation would grind to a halt?
When a free tool that anyone can accidentally delete, corrupt, or overwrite becomes the backbone of your business — that's a risk, not a tool.
The telltale sign: The thought of the spreadsheet being unavailable for a day makes you genuinely anxious.
What Comes Next (And What Doesn't)
If you recognized your business in three or more of those signs, you've outgrown spreadsheets. But the solution isn't what most people expect.
It's Not a $50,000 ERP System
The enterprise software world will happily sell you a system that takes six months to implement, costs more than your annual rent, and requires a dedicated admin to manage. For a 10-person business, that's overkill.
It's Not "Just Get a Better Spreadsheet"
Airtable, Notion, Monday.com — these are all great tools. They're also still fundamentally spreadsheet-shaped. They'll buy you time, but if your problem is that your business processes have outgrown a grid of rows and columns, a fancier grid won't fix it. (We compared the build vs. buy tradeoff in detail in Custom Software vs. Off-the-Shelf.)
What Actually Works
The next step for most small businesses is a simple, purpose-built system that does exactly what your spreadsheet does — but properly.
That means a real database instead of rows in a grid. A real user interface instead of column headers and conditional formatting. Real access controls instead of "please don't edit column F." Real automation instead of copy-paste workflows and manual scripts.
It doesn't have to be complicated. For most businesses, the first version — your MVP — looks remarkably simple. A form for input. A list view with filters and search. A dashboard with the three or four numbers you actually care about. Maybe some automated notifications.
The difference isn't complexity. It's reliability. The data won't break when someone sorts the wrong column. The system works on a phone. Multiple people can use it without stepping on each other. And when you ask "how many new customers this quarter?" the answer takes one second, not thirty minutes.
The Transition
Moving off a critical spreadsheet feels scary. It shouldn't.
The smartest approach is to run both systems in parallel for a while. The new system handles new data. The spreadsheet keeps running with historical data. Once you're confident the new system works, you migrate the history and retire the sheet.
Nobody wakes up one morning and throws away their spreadsheet. It's a gradual transition — and that's fine.
The Real Question
If you're reading this and thinking "that's us," ask yourself: what is the spreadsheet actually costing you?
Not in dollars — in time. In mistakes. In questions you've stopped asking. In the anxiety of knowing that one accidental deletion could wreck your week. And if your data is also scattered across 12 other apps, the spreadsheet is just the visible symptom of a bigger problem.
Spreadsheets are tools, not infrastructure. They're great for analysis, quick calculations, and temporary tracking. They're terrible as the operational backbone of a growing business.
The sign that you've outgrown them isn't that they stop working. It's that they keep working — just barely, with increasing effort, and with growing risk.
Ready to graduate from spreadsheets? We build simple, purpose-built systems for small businesses — designed around how you actually work. No enterprise bloat, no six-month implementations. Let's start with a conversation.
Related Posts
Stay Connected
Follow us for practical insights on using technology to grow your business.